Is Success Smiled Upon More in the US Than Elsewhere?

While I’m buried in the Musk series, I thought I’d open things up on an interesting point he made. Musk is from South Africa, but he moved to the US in his early 20s and never left. Speaking about the benefits for him of living in the US, he mentions what he sees as an important distinction in the attitude toward success in the US versus other places. He says:

I think the United States is more open to new ideas than any country in the world. And I think it becomes somewhat of a self-fulfilling prophecy in that because the United States is open to new ideas, it attracted people from around the world who had new ideas. So now it’s filled with people who like new ideas and who aren’t bound by history. DT28 - PA lot of countries that have been around for a long time are really trapped in their own history. The United States…is a country that tends to encourage success—where you see someone that did extremely well, and generally the reaction in the United States is, ‘Good for that person.’ In most countries, that’s not the reaction. People tend to think, ‘Oh, that person did well because they screwed somebody else.’ Or that they tried to rise beyond their station, that it was really inappropriate of them to be so nouveau riche, to use a French word. Australia, for example, which is arguably similar to the United States in a lot of ways, but they tend to try to knock down people that have risen too high—they call it the Tall Poppy Syndrome, you know, tall poppies get chopped. So I think that’s really a good thing about the United States.

I’m curious what Wait But Why readers think of this. Is he correct that that’s the attitude in the United States? Is he correct that the attitude towards success is different in many other countries? How does your society or culture view individual success?


You can sign up for the Dinner Table email list here to be notified about the new topic each week, and remember to submit future topic suggestions to

Home Archive